Full Case Name:  Her Majesty the Queen and Menard

Share |
Country of Origin:  Canada Court Name:  Quebec Court of Appeal Primary Citation:  R v. Menard 1978 CarswellQue 25 Date of Decision:  Tuesday, July 11, 1978 Judge Name:  Lamer J.A. Alternate Citation:  R v. Menard (1978) 43 C.C.C. (2d) 458 Judges:  LajoieJ.A. Belanger J.A. Attorneys:  L. G. Robichaud, Q.C., for the Crown. D. R. Lanctôt, for respondent. Docket Num:  Montreal No. 500-10-000313-773
Summary: The accused in R v. Menard had a business euthanizing animals by use of motor exhaust which caused pain and burns to the mucous membranes of the animals he was euthanizing. In a decision written by future Canadian Supreme Court Chief Justice, Lamer J. overturned a decision from the lower courts and reinstated the original conviction. Lamer J. statements about the animal-human relationship have been influential in Canadian Animal case law.
Documents:  PDF icon R v Menard.pdf (2.82 MB)
Share |