www.animallaw.info




Search the Site:       

Search Tips


DONATIONS

Click Here to make a tax deductible donation.


Select by State




Select by Topic


Select by Subject




Select by Species




World Law




Additional Categories









 


Teaching Textbook for Animals in the Legal System

Prof. David Favre: Animal: Welfare, Interests & Rights

 

 

ISBN # 0-9724103-5-X, 503 pages in 81/2 x 11 format.

ISBN # 0-9724103-6-8, e-book version, .pdf format that keeps same page references as hard copy.

 

Table of Contents  / Sample chapter – Standing .pdf

 

This book is to be used primarily for the teaching of animal law. While the primary focus is for law school use, others may find it a useful introduction to a wide set of legal materials. It contains cases, text, and problems for most of the issues that arise dealing with animals. The electronic edition also contains over 350 footnotes with extensive legal references for the practicing lawyer. (If you teach a course with this book, contact the author for some teaching reference materials.)

 

Available as:

 

  1. Hard bound book ($78, bookstore link )
  2. Electronic book (350 footnotes added) – download from web as .pdf file ($32, bookstore link or can be shipped on a CD ($36, bookstore link ).

 

Please note that this book is only available by credit card purchase on the web or by check to the Animal Legal & Historical Web Center.

 

It may also be order by sending a check to:

 

Animal Legal and Historical Web Center - Business Manager

Michigan State University College of Law

Shaw Lane

East Lansing, MI  48824-1300

 

Please add shipping cost of $3.00 per for disk copy and $6.00 per for bound copy (standard UPS). 

 

 

Table of Contents

 

Topic 1 An Introduction 1

1. Cowboys Kill Cowbirds 1

2. Poisonings 1

3. Horses 2

4. It All Started With the Greeks 3

5. Rene Descartes 7

6. Voltaire, Animals in Philosophical Dictionary 8

7. AMA Surveys Public About Attitudes Towards Animals 9

8. Use of Chimpanzees in Research and Entertainment 9

9. A Little More History 10

10. An Old Case 12

11. The Voice of West Virginia 15

 

PART 1 — ANIMALS IN OUR LEGAL SYSTEM: PRIVATE LAW

 

Topic 2 Title and Ownership 21

1. What is Ownership? 21

2. The Distinction Between Wild and Domestic Animals 26

3. Dogs As Property—A Special Case 29

4. Obtaining and Transferring Ownership 30

5. Interference with Ownership 36

6. Responsibility for Ownership 38

7. The Issues of Status 47

 

Topic 3 Bailments 55

1. The Creation and Nature of Bailments 55

2. Duties of Bailor and Bailee 56

3. Bailor’s Recovery for Loss or Injury of Bailed Animal 57

4. Injury to Bailee by Animal: Horse Rentals 63

5. Injury to Third Party by Bailed Animals 70

6. The Creation and Components of an Agistment Bailment 71

 

Topic 4 Veterinarian Malpractice 73

1. Introduction 73

2. Scope of Liability 80

3. Malpractice Distinguished 81

4. Malpractice Generally 83

5. Determining the Standard of Treatment 83

6. Scope of Professional Responsibility 88

7. Proximate Cause 88

8. The Alternative of Res Ipsa Loquitur 92

9. Revocation of License to Practice 92

Practice Pointers For the Owners of Animals 95

 

Topic 5 Damages 97

1. Overview 97

2. Legal Rights of Animal Ownership 97

3. Injury to Animals by Another—Torts 98

4. Overview of Damages for Injury to Animals 99

5. The Traditional Calculation—Fair Market Value 100

6. Consequential Damages 108

7. Intrinsic Value 109

8. Punitive Damages 109

9. Mental Anguish or Suffering of the Owner 111

10. Loss of Companionship 119

 

Topic 6 Private Regulation of Ownership—

Landlords & Condos & Home Owners 127

1. Pets Within A Lease 127

2. Defenses Available to Tenants 132

3. Condominiums 138

4. Subdivision Covenants 144

 

PART 2 — ANIMALS IN OUR LEGAL SYSTEM: PUBLIC LAW

 

Topic 7 State Regulation of Ownership 157

1. Police Power Generally 157

2. Limitations on Police Power—Constitutional Rights 164

3. Federal Preemption of State Law 170

4. Dangerous Dogs 171

5. Local Government—Nuisance and Zoning 177

6. Limitations on Local Authority 181

7. Actions of State Agents 184

 

Topic 8 Anti-Cruelty Laws—History & Intentional Acts 189

1. Historical Perspective 189

A. The Legal Framework in the United States 190

B. Early American Legislation 190

C. The Bergh Era Begins 194

D. New Legislation 194

2. Intentional Acts 200

A. Who is liable? Which humans? 200

B. Which Animals Are Protected? 202

C. What Is Cruel? 205

D. Torture Torment, or Injury 209

E. Criminal Sentencing 216

Appendix A: The 1867 New York Anti-Cruelty Law 217

Appendix B: Michigan - General Prohibitions Against Cruelty 219

 

Topic 9 Anti-Cruelty Laws, Care, Constitution & Defenses 227

1. Duty to Provide Care 227

A. Which Animals, Which People? 228

B. Scope of the Duty of Care 231

2. Individual Constitutional Rights 238

3. Defense of Self and Property 248

4. Defense of Animal Training 253

Appendix A: Michigan—General Prohibitions Against Cruelty 254

 

Topic 10 Hunting, Science, Agriculture and Animal Fighting 263

1. Hunting and Fishing 264

2. Scientific Research 268

3. Agricultural Use of Animals 271

4. Animal Fighting 278

Appendix A: Full Text of Florida Initiative 285

Appendix B: Michigan—Animal Fighting Provisions 286

 

Topic 11 Control of Wildlife 291

1. State Ownership Doctrine 291

2. Limitations on State Control 300

3. State Management Agencies—Creation 303

4. Scope of Authority Under the Police Power 306

5. The Science/ Management Content 308

6. Ethical Context 313

 

PART 3 — ANIMALS AND FEDERAL LAW

 

Topic 12 Access to Courts—Standing 323

1. Introduction 323

2. Environmental Standing—The ESA 332

3. Standing for Individual Animals 338

4. Breakthrough Standing for AWA Issues 343

Appendix A: Portions of the Endangered Species Act 353

 

Topic 13 The Animal Welfare Act—Generally 357

1. Introduction 357

2. Growth of the Federal Law 359

3. Animals Sold to Research,Teaching and Testing 362

4. Class A and B Dealers 370

5. Which Other Animals 378

6. Regulatory Permits and Inspections 382

Appendix A: Provisions of the AWA 389

Appendix B: Selected Regulations 392

 

Topic 14 Animals in Science 401

1. Policy Discussion—The Nature of Science 401

2. Legal Framework and the Scope of AWA 409

3. Institutional Animal Care Committees 428

Appendix A: What is Pain & What Relieves it? 430

Appendix B: Provisions of AWA 432

Appendix C: An ACUC Proposal 437

Appendix D: What is Science about? 444

 

PART 4 — ANIMAL RIGHTS

 

Topic 15 Animal Rights—The Jurisprudence 449

1. Philosophy & Religion—Moral Perspectives 449

2. Jurisprudence—What is A Right? An Interest? 459

3. Basis for Legal Recognition 464

4. Future Possibilities 466

 

Topic 16 Animal Rights—The Social Movement 475

1. The Breadth of the Animal Movement 475

2. The Nature of the Debate 475

3. Activist Interaction with Criminal Law 485

 

Cases

Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Glickman (1998) 344

Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Glickman (2000) 420

Berlangieri v. Running Elk Corporation 64

Brown v. Muhlenbery Township 184

C.E.A.S.E. v. The New England Aquarium 330

Coho Salmon (et al) v. Pacifi c Lumber Company 332

Commonwealth v. Ebaugh 178

Commonwealth v. Turner 203

Dillon v. O’Connor 101

Dubner v. City and County of San Francisco 485

Eastep v. Veterinary Medical Examining Board 92

Elisea v. State (civil malpractice) 78

Elisea v. State (criminal cruelty) 213

Gebert v. Yank 58

Geer v. Connecticut 291

Grise v. State 196

Horton v. State 207

In re: David M. Zimmerman 373

In re: Judie Hansen 384

In re: Lee Roach and Roach Laboratories, Inc. 406

In re: Marilyn Shepherd 383

IPPL v. Institute for Behavioral Research, Inc. 339

Jordan v. U.S. 231

Leblanc v. Underwriters at Lloyd’s 103

Longhi v. APHIS 376

Mescalero Apache Tribe v. New Mexico 297

Montana v. Fertterer 23

Noble v. Murphy 140

North Carolina v. Stewart 306

Peoples Program for Endangered Species v. Sexton 165

People v. Banqued 280

People v. Rogers 238

People v. Thomason 244

People v. Tinsdale 12

People v. Voelker 241

Phillips v. San Luis Obispo County 167

Price v. Brown 73

Rabideau v. City of Racine 112

Raymond v. Lachmann 48

Ridgewood Homeowners Association v. Mignacca 144

Ruden v. Hansen 84

Sierra Club v. Morton 326

Southall v. Gabel 88

State v. Avery 211, 253

State v. Bruner 200

State v. Cleve 264

State v. Dresbach 235

State v. Klammer 228

State v. Ruisi 173

State v. Smith 43

State v. Wrobel 207, 250

Stephens v. State 249

Taub v. State 268

The Pines of Boca Barwood

Condominium Association, Inc. v. Cavouti 138

The Town of Bethel v. Roslyn West 158

Turudic v. Stephens 152

Warren County Combined Health District v. Rittenhouse 26

Williams v. Johnson 39

Young v. Savinon 129